And there is nothing being put forward by the old-school libertarian campaign crowd that has been able to undo the damage being done by a hardcore set of misguided geek activists.
There is nothing like the internet filter debate to bring out the worst in people. And so it has been with the reaction to my last column chiding internet ferals.
Yes, the term 'internet ferals' is inflammatory and unnecessary. You're right. You got me there. But the debate within the tech community has been so counterproductive, and so full of disinformation and rubbish, I simply could not help myself.
Forgive me, please.
Nah, I don't mean that. There is an element of the anti-filter crowd that has been so damaging to the broader, mainstream campaign that they need to be called out. If you don't like the term internet ferals, think of yourselves as idiots. You know who you are.
In the meantime, here are some thoughts about the campaign, which is not going well.
There are some real problems. Not least that this noisy minority is killing any chance of bringing onboard the mass of reasonably-minded, moderate, everyday Australian voters that are needed to effectively influence the process.
And that makes it difficult for the Opposition senators who are uncomfortable with the filter plan. It makes it more difficult for them to get vocal, let alone try and bring their colleagues along with them.
For the benefit of the noisy minority: It helps to be positive. It is more effective to be FOR something, rather than simply AGAINST something else.
Much better to argue the very real merits of the existing open regime for the internet - to put forward the very reasonable case that the existing environment has served us well. It is much more productive to point out what we are putting at risk by considering even this mild set of internet censorship plans.
Secondly, abuse does not help. Whether the abuse is aimed at Stephen Conroy, his staff, Kevin Rudd, journalists, or others in an electronic forum who might wonder aloud whether there should be limits to freedom of expression, abuse does nothing except distract potential supporters from the reasonable arguments that the anti-filter campaign has at its disposal.
Thirdly, the disinformation and hyperbole being put forward by the extreme elements of the debate are a gross distortion to the point of being fundamentally dishonest. Start campaigning against the scheme that is being introduced rather campaigning against a more sinister made-up version of it. Dishonesty does not impress people.
Stop whining. And stop the obsession with Stephen Conroy as being some kind of Dark Rider in league with the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. The filter started as ALP policy (if poorly articulated) and has been a policy of this Government.
The policy started life in a kind of game of one-upmanship with the then Coalition government, which saw votes in cleaning up the internet and which had a backbench full of filter agitators. Then Communications Minister Helen Coonan was saddled with that particularly turd sandwich, and managed to hose it down as best she could.
Conroy inherited this policy. Who knows what he actually feels about it, and who cares? Cabinet wants it done and the Government could not have been clearer about its intentions.
Start talking to people who can actually influence the process. And at this point, that is the Liberal Party. The Greens have already said they will vote against filter. Which means the government needs the Opposition to vote with it to get the filter passed in the Senate.
There are a many Opposition senators who are uncomfortable with the very notion of an internet filter. But there are many who are supportive of it. And you do the moderates no favours by seeding the debate with intentionally misinformed vitriol.
Finally, the No Clean Feed slogan is completely ridiculous and counterproductive. Not exactly the kind of message that is likely to capture the imagination of millions of time-poor mum's and dad's who already feel uncomfortable with the internet. While the Electronic Frontiers Australia organisation is now doing something about this, it is very late in the game.
To paraphrase my colleague David Heath, the campaign would do itself a favour if it stopped presenting itself as outraged geeks and started to instead behave like informed and reasonable voters.
Featured IT News
Australian Open Banking provider Frollois partnering with customer-owned bank, Beyond Bank, using Frollo’s CDR gateway to improve multi-banking and lending…
With Apple arguably the world's most advanced SoC maker for smartphones, tablets and computers, the ARM and x86 competition is…
Australia’s Cyber Security Growth Network AustCyber has relaunched AUCyberExplorer, an interactive tool that tracks the state of the Australian cyber…
APAC cloud solutions and service distributor rhipe says its guaranteed lead generation and growth program is accelerating value for partners,…
At today's AWS re:Invent 2021 conference in Las Vegas the company announced robots take centre stage in the company’s future…
Melbourne-founded mobile payments company Mr Yum has raised $89 million in a Series A funding round led by investment firm…
Intel has appointed Steven A. Long as general manager of Asia Pacific and Japan (APJ) region.
Businesses of all sizes recognise there is valuable information hidden within their troves of data, yet AWS research identified 62%…
Existing methods to detect and nab cyber criminals are likely to be ineffective in the years ahead, judging from the…
Super taxes proposed by Papua New Guinea will hit Telstra in its role as owner of Digicel, with the telco…
This year's OWASP Top 10 underwent some significant restructuring. A few vendors offered their thoughts.
TPG Telecom says it has set a world record for a long-range video and voice call on a 5G network…
The Australian arm of a global initiative working to counter digital threats to democracy says the Federal Government's proposed new…
The Federal Government will put in place new rules to force technology companies to identify anonymous online trolls, or be…
Young Australians are taking the charge in navigating their own safety experience online, with nearly three quarters of teens -…
Breaking IT News
Remote access specialist TeamViewer has appointed Sojung Lee to the new role of president for the Asia-Pacific region.
The 2021 Business Book of the Year has been awarded to author Tracy Sheen for her book The End of…
Business process automation company Checkbox has signed an agreement with PwC Australia to accelerate the digital transformation and optimisation of…
New retail data from Eftpos has revealed the Black Friday sales surge moved beyond online to music shops, fashion outlets,…
Four Mallee councils have joined forces to trial Internet of Things (IoT) technology to inform decision-making and improve operational efficiencies.
The Singapore Infocomm Media Authority (IMDA), the Singapore equivalent of the ACMA, announced the results of its 2.1 GHz spectrum…
Disciplined control engineering solutions Q-Ctrl has secured a Series B fundraise of US$25 million led by Airbus Ventures.
Water industry company Melbourne Water, a government-owned authority which manages major water, sewerage, and drainage networks across Greater Melbourne, has…
Brisbane-based CX and MarTech agency Triggerfish has appointed Oliver Brown to the role of UK head of UI design.
Make sure your website stands up to Black Friday and Cyber Monday levels of traffic with commercetools01 December 2021 in Business Software
Black Friday and Cyber Monday have been, with 8.9 million Australian shoppers spending $5.4 billion. Retailers need to be sure…
Much of what we do in the last 20 months or so has changed to become end-to-end digital experiences and…
Nokia 5G standalone private wireless network to support Industry 4.0 adoption at Agnico Eagle Finland mining operations
The 1MORE ColorBuds 2 - tiny earbuds, big sound
While you might not know of 1MORE, this stylish electronic audio company headquartered in San Diego and Shenzhen…in Computers & peripherals
Enhance your audio with the Cyber Acoustics SP-2000 speakerphone and CA-2890 USB speaker bar
Cyber Acoustics has been producing premium audio products for a fraction of competitor prices for 25 years. In…in Computers & peripherals
Review: the time is just right for the OPPO A16s to emerge
Strange though it be, the smartphone that's been released at the time best suited for it this year,…in Smartphones & Mobile devices
The Vissles LP85 mechanical keyboard brings out your inner creativity
A great writer, programmer, analyst, leader deserves a great keyboard. Vissles is no slouch when it comes to…in Computers & peripherals
PRODUCT PROMOTION - Five reasons why you need Zebra's ET80/ET85 (ET8X) Rugged Tablet
Although the needs of every worker out in the field will be different, there are undeniable factors that…in Computers & peripherals
Dominate the enemy with the Corsair M65 RGB Ultra Wireless mouse
A great gamer needs a great mouse, and Corsair's latest mouse comes with sub-millisecond transmission, a 26,000 DPI…in Computers & peripherals
- The EPOS H3 Hybrid gaming headset plays wherever you do Computers & peripherals
Manage your blood pressure and more with the 3-in-1 wireless Withings BPM Core
French-based medical IoT company Withings continues to deliver with its wireless blood pressure monitor, developed with cardiologists and…in Computers & peripherals
Make your laptop a battle station with the Aten USB-C multiport dock with power pass-through
Today's laptops of all makes and models are super-portable devices. Yet, there's a time when you want to…in Computers & peripherals
Review: OPPO A94 5G is the big brother of budget 5G phones
The OPPO A94 5G is the third low-budget model from this Chinese vendor released this year, and also…in Smartphones & Mobile devices
- Sit straight with the CZUR Mirror AI posture checker Computers & peripherals
The Razer Barracuda X headset games wherever you do
Iconic gaming hardware brand, Razer, has unleashed its new four-in-one gaming headset that provides a wireless and cabled…in Computers & peripherals
Review: vivo Y52 5G joins the mob jostling for sales in Australia
vivo's Y52 5G is a worthy addition to the ever-increasing range of low-budget smartphones that include the new…in Smartphones & Mobile devices
The Cyber Acoustics HS-2000 headset is the no-fuss work-all-day business headset
The Cyber Acoustics HS-2000 headset is a no-fuss, business-grade USB headset that fits comfortably, has an adjustable boom…in Computers & peripherals
The Corsair Virtuoso RGB wireless XT is the gaming headset that gives and gives
Corsair's reputation for quality PC components continues with its brand new Virtuoso RGB wireless XT headset, delivering high-fidelity…in Computers & peripherals
Op-ed on electric vehicles omits facts that don't suit its arguments
An op-ed in The Australian, which accuses journalists at the ABC and Guardian Australia of failing to provide…in Open Sauce
Liberal Senator girds his loins for more humiliation by Facebook
The Australian Government, it appears, does not believe in the old saying, "once bitten, twice shy". After being…in Open Sauce
Malcolm Turnbull needs to explain dodgy cut-down NBN rollout figures
Malcolm Turnbull has some explaining to do about the costs of the NBN this morning, after Guardian Australia…in Open Sauce
ABC's Four Corners housing price report silent on money laundering
The ABC, which claims to be Australia's "most trusted news service", failed to tell its viewers, during an…in Open Sauce
Telstra in box seat to buy NBN Co after its Digicel deal
After a long time, Telstra has literally hit the jackpot with a business move: the company has fallen…in Open Sauce
- News Corp reporter uses weasel words to push tired claims about Huawei Open Sauce
DTA not saying if firms certified as cloud hosts have compliance issues
The Digital Transformation Agency, now vested with the responsibility for certifying cloud companies that can host government data,…in Open Sauce
- ABC iview user data collected through Google Analytics stored in the US Open Sauce
ASPI's Jennings beats the war drums again; maybe budgets are strained?
It looks like the defence industry lobby group, the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, is running low on funds.…in Open Sauce
Ziggy Switkowski steps down with Kate McKenzie to take over as new Chair of NBN Co
The offices of Paul Fletcher Minister for Communications Urban Infrastructure Cities and the Arts and Simon Birmingham Minister…in Telecoms & NBN
Gary Smith awarded 2021 Communications Ambassador at ACOMMS
Telecommunications icon, Mr Gary Smith, has taken out the Australian communication industry’s most prestigious accolade; being awarded the…in Telecoms & NBN
- Telstra-owned Digicel may face $36m in new PNG tax Telecoms & NBN
MNF Group Limited name change to Symbio Holdings Limited now effective
Symbio Holdings Limited (ASX: SYM, “the Company”) (formerly MNF Group Limited (ASX: MNF)) has advised that following shareholder…in Telecoms & NBN
Veyor secures $4 million funding to double its workforce and ramp development projects
Technology company Veyor has raised $4 million in funding, earning equity capital and financial support from investors.in Deals
Oracle ERP users win big with BlackLine according to Nucleus Research
By BlackLineCOMPANY NEWS: Nucleus calculates Oracle ERP users achieve payback in under a year, generate US $2.58 for every…in Deals
Hesta invests $120 million in Citadel Group
Australian industry superannunation fund for health workers Hesta invests a $120 million equity stake in IT service management…in Deals
Young Australians boost confidence to challenge cyberbullying with Digital Ambassadors program
By Staff WriterYoung Australians are taking the charge in navigating their own safety experience online, with nearly three quarters of…in Home Tech
- InPayTech is now wrkr IT Industry
The e-scooter revolution is being re-ignited with Meredot's next-gen 'wireless fuelling stations' for micro-mobility transport
Eco-friendly, universal, scalable wireless docking stations for all popular e-scooters with management functions and extra safety capabilities has…in Home Tech
Fears about real agenda behind Online Safety Bill after US podcast
Fears have arisen about the agenda of the eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant after the news website Crikey…in Technology Regulation
Schneider Electric hires Hopkins
Schneider Electric has appointed Patricia Hopkins to the role of director of its distributed software and business development…in People Moves
GoPro announces Black Friday sales on the HERO10 high-performance, high-portability action camera
GoPro has announced Black Friday price reductions on its latest HERO10 camera with the new high-performance G2 processor…in Deals
The End of Fortnite is coming on 5 December
Mega-popular gaming phenomenon Fortnite is bringing players together in a last stand against the Cube Queen in its…in Entertainment
ACS elects Nick Tate as 2022-23 national president
By Staff WriterThe Australian Computer Society (ACS) has elected Nick Tate as national president for 2022-23 to replace Dr Ian…in People Moves
Travel virtually around the world inside Heygo
Travel is no longer what it was due to COVID-19 regulations, but with tip-based live-streaming platform Heygo, anyone…in Entertainment