Warning this article may contain opinions of the author that you and iTWire don't necessarily agree with. Don't let them get away with it - have your say with a comment!

No. 1 Story

ACCC clears Optus to scrap HFC network and use NBN instead

The ACCC has cleared, provisionally, the proposed deal between Optus and NBN Co under which Optus is to be paid around $800m to shut down its HFC network and transfer customers onto the NBN. read more

What are the odds?

Opinion and Analysis

The recent announcement that the Bulgarian lottery produced the same six numbers in two consecutive draws left many observers making accusations of 'scam.'  However the maths may not support such a conclusion.

Let's start with a simple question: "How do lotteries work?" 

In the abstract, they operate by randomly selecting a fixed set of numbers from a larger pool.  For instance, they might select 6 numbers from a pool of 42 (as was the case in Bulgaria).  The exact method is irrelevant; they might use numbered ping-pong balls, perhaps a computer random-number generator or any other method; as long as it can be guaranteed to be random.

This immediately raises some confining rules.

Firstly, that once selected, a number cannot be re-selected.  In other words, duplicates are not allowed.

Secondly, order is not important.  Choosing 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 produces exactly the same result as 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 (or any other combination). In fact, the Bulgarian lottery did produce the numbers in different order.

So, what are the odds of any specific set of numbers?  Let's calculate the odds of winning the Bulgarian lottery (based on drawing numbered balls from a bucket).  Being limited by the two confining rules, we know that the odds of a player choosing the first ball are 1 in 42.  However, for the second ball the odds are only 1 in 41 (because a ball has already been removed from the pool).  Subsequently, it reduces with each ball drawn out.

So, in order to match the balls as they are drawn, our player has odds of 1:42 x 1:41 x 1:40 etc down to 1:37.  This is a huge number - approximately 1:3.78 billion.  On that basis, no-one would ever win!

However, we have not constrained ourselves by the second rule.