Warning this article may contain opinions of the author that you and iTWire don't necessarily agree with. Don't let them get away with it - have your say with a comment!

No. 1 Story

ACCC clears Optus to scrap HFC network and use NBN instead

The ACCC has cleared, provisionally, the proposed deal between Optus and NBN Co under which Optus is to be paid around $800m to shut down its HFC network and transfer customers onto the NBN. read more

Victorians to get identity cards masked as driving licences

Opinion and Analysis

Just like Australian passports, the photograph in the licence will be analysed and stored in a facial recognition database.  So, no more smiling for the VicRoads camera!

The media release quotes a wonderful piece of marketing babble which must surely have come from the suppliers of the facial recognition system.  "Facial recognition is the most effective way to identify driver licence fraud. The technology analyses almost 170 points on the human face and translates the information into a mathematical formula, or template, and searches for likely matches in the system."

This is the technical equivalent of "eleven spices and herbs."

"VicRoads will then investigate any potential matches and hand over suspected fraud cases to Victoria Police. This work will make it harder than ever for people to collect a number of licences for multiple identities."

What the release doesn't say is what initially happens when a match is found.  In other, similar systems iTWire is aware of; all 'interesting' photos are passed to a human to confirm whether or not they really are closely related.  This occurs long before any accusations of fraud are made as there is no ability for the system to guarantee a match.

There will be some amusing side-effects from this technology.  For instance, authorities will be able to note which licences are NOT renewed and go knocking on doors to find out why, especially when the photo on an old licence looks a lot like a new one (in a different name).

Also, if the Australian passport procedures are anything to go by, there will also be mistakes.  Stories of errors are quite common – for instance, there was one reported case of a Caucasian woman receiving her new passport with the photo of an Asian man in it!  These are much less likely to occur in a store-front production facility and much more easily corrected than when the production is separated from the consumer.

Finally, there is no mention of "mission creep."  We are not told whether the facial recognition database is a closed system or whether it will be used to (for instance) attempt matches with Melbourne Mayor Robert Doyle's street surveillance cameras.  Neither are we told of other features - perhaps embedded RFID tags.