The Government has offered Australia's three mobile operators, and vividwireless, renewal of their existing spectrum allocated on 15 year licences in the late 90s and early 2000s at set prices, while the Government expects to rake in $3 billion.
Roberts effectively says, “yes, Stephen Hemminger did post that initial blog entry. Yes, Stephen Hemminger did find Microsoft had linked closed source code with open source code. Yes, this is factual and the events described happened.”
Roberts then says that Stephen Hemminger is a good guy (and I’m sure he is) and he wasn’t trying to catch Microsoft out but simply solve a technical problem. He found a conflict and called Greg Kroah-Hartman at Novell and asked him to speak with Microsoft.
The thrust of Roberts’ argument is simply Vyatta did not “accuse” Microsoft of violating the GPL, in the sense Vyatta did not post blog entries mocking Microsoft or saying “gotcha!”
Rather, Vyatta discovered there was a licensing violation and took steps to educate Microsoft about it. There can be no doubt that this ultimately led to Microsoft’s submitting the source code to the Linux kernel. One clearly caused the other.
This whole denial then, by Microsoft, seems rather hollow. The “rebuttal” is anything but. It is merely a re-iteration that the events did happen, just Vyatta chose not to bask in triumph at discovering a Microsoft foible.
Nevertheless, the test for whether a license violation occurred is not based on the intentions of those who uncover it. It is based on the actions of the company that combined GPL code with proprietary code.
The “perception” of a license violation is not based on whether the people who discovered it were good guys but whether, simply put, the license was violated. Which it was. The so-called “rebuttal” Ramji refers us to actually confirms this happened.
So there you have it. I’m sorry, Microsoft. You did violate the GNU public license. The fact Stephen Hemminger at heart wanted to produce a great system instead of rubbing your nose in it is more a matter of good fortune than a wondrous reinvention of the license terms.
David Bass
| ComOps, a leading Australian provider of business software products and services, has won a competitive tender to deploy its Salvus safety, r…
How to Make Business Discovery Work for Your Business
Business Discovery takes its cues from consumer apps. Like Google, it encourages us- ers to hunt for and explore data without worrying about or even noticing the underly- ing technology. Their entire experience is working within an intuitive interface to get real-time, self-service results with only minimal training. ...more
Try an easy-to-use set of web-enabled
tools for business-class productivity services. Office 365 provides
anywhere-access to email, important documents, contacts, and calendars
on almost any device.
