Warning this article may contain opinions of the author that you and iTWire don't agree with.
Visit the last page to have your say in our forum.

No. 1 Story

Mobile operators get fixed price spectrum renewal in $3b Government windfall

The Government has offered Australia's three mobile operators, and vividwireless, renewal of their existing spectrum allocated on 15 year licences in the late 90s and early 2000s at set prices, while the Government expects to rake in $3 billion.

read more

Mono: Why is Debian resorting to spin?

Opinion and Analysis


When communications people try to clarify things, they often end up doing worse than they did the first time and tie themselves in knots. Reichle-Schmehl is no exception.

It was left to the cantankerous Mouette to write a Q and A in his own style, answering what should have been answered and adding a couple of personal slurs against me, Millan, BoycottNovell editor Roy Schestowitz and Stallman.

Reichle-Schmehl's spin wasn't very good. He tried to use the fact that statistics from the popularity contest package - which checks the packages installed and reports back to the Debian project for analysis of usage -  indicate that Mono was being installed as default only for some users.

But on looking closely at the statistics he provided it is clear that this subset is nearly 20 percent of the users in question.

There are a couple of things that come to mind here. First, the popularity-contest application is not installed by default - as with many other things that happen during a Debian install, the project has ensured that the installation of this bit of software is a choice made by the user.

Many users consider even pop-con intrusive and do not install it - I have foux boxes running three ports of Debian and I have not installed it on a single one. Which means the statistics put out by pop-con are really not all that reliable.

But even if they are, 20 percent is a fairly big slice of one's userbase, not some inconsequential group.

The question of using applications that are dependent on Mono has been a vexatious one for a long time. Nobody in the FOSS community has ever raised an objection to the provision of the packages by any GNU/Linux distribution; it's only the question of making these applications a part of the default set that has resulted in endless arguments.

The Debian project has shown no inclination to discuss the issue on its mailing lists either, though most contentious issues are thrashed out there. This is a strange departure from the norm and leaves the door fully open for conjecture.

It would be good to see a statement, couched in plain language, from the project about its Mono stance.

Loading comments ...



- sponsored feature -

The Death of Traditional BI: What’s Next?

How to Make Business Discovery Work for Your Business IP PABX BUYING GUIDE

Business Discovery takes its cues from consumer apps. Like Google, it encourages us- ers to hunt for and explore data without worrying about or even noticing the underly- ing technology. Their entire experience is working within an intuitive interface to get real-time, self-service results with only minimal training. ...more