Warning this article may contain opinions of the author that you and iTWire don't necessarily agree with. Don't let them get away with it - have your say with a comment!

No. 1 Story

ACCC clears Optus to scrap HFC network and use NBN instead

The ACCC has cleared, provisionally, the proposed deal between Optus and NBN Co under which Optus is to be paid around $800m to shut down its HFC network and transfer customers onto the NBN. read more

Minchin claims Conroy and Tanner at odds over Telstra break-up

Opinion and Analysis

"An undertaking comes into force when it is accepted by the ACCC. Telstra will not be allowed to supply services using a designated part of the spectrum unless all three undertakings given by Telstra are in force.

"However, the Minister may exempt Telstra from the requirement to have an undertaking about hybrid fibre-coaxial networks or subscription television broadcasting licences if the Minister is satisfied that Telstra's undertaking about structural separation is sufficient to address concerns about the degree of Telstra's power in telecommunications markets."

So there you have it. At the end of the day whether Telstra has to get rid of its HFC networks and its Foxtel stake comes down to a ministerial judgement; a judgement which is, presumably appealable by Telstra if it disagrees and moreover a judgement likely to be very hard to quantify.

For one thing, many have concerns about Telstra's market power that go beyond its vertical integration. As the former monopoly and by far the largest telco it enjoys economies of scale, levels of brand awareness, size of customer base, high street presence and breadth and depth of retail product portfolio that will continue to give it huge advantages even if an effective wholesale + network/retail split is implemented.

In other words, if the minister is determined to force divestiture of HFC and Foxtel on Telstra, he can probably do it. Note that, in contrast, Telstra's access to spectrum is dependent only on the separation undertaking being acceptable to the ACCC, not on ministerial judgement as to whether or not it is "sufficient to address concerns about the degree of Telstra's power in telecommunications markets."

Need all the latest news on telecommunications?
If telecoms is your business: you'll find in-depth, industry-specific news, analysis and commentary in ExchangeDaily
Check out a recent edition (no forms to fill in) or take a free trial