Blog

Technology news and Jobs arrow Our Blogs arrow Open Sauce arrow Memo to Reuters: stop spreading FUD about Novell and Linux
Memo to Reuters: stop spreading FUD about Novell and Linux E-mail
by Sam Varghese   
Monday, 05 February 2007
The British news agency Reuters came up with a sensational bit of spin on Friday, US time, claiming that the Free Software Foundation could "ban" Novell from selling Linux.

Good headline, but very weak on facts. Here's a FAQ that I've written for Jim Finkle, the intrepid Reuters reporter who filed that story:

Can the FSF ban Novell from selling Linux?

No, the FSF cannot ban Novell (and indeed anybody else) from selling Linux. The Linux kernel is under the second version of the General Public Licence (GPLv2). Linus Torvalds holds the copyright to the kernel.

Anything and everything which is included in a distribution of Linux - which I call GNU/Linux because it contains a fair few bits and pieces from the GNU Foundation, a sister organisation of the FSF - is included only if the terms of its licence are compatible with the GPLv2.

Why is this story circulating?

In November last year, Novell signed a deal with Microsoft that has angered a major part of the free and open source software community. The deal does not violate the GPLv2 in word. However, in my opinion, (and that of many others), it does violate GPLv2 in spirit.

What then can the FSF do? Why is this misinformation being spread?

As to why misinformation is being spread, the reporter probably didn't have a clue about the subject he set out to tackle. "Ban" is a very good word to pull readers.

The FSF holds the copyright on a number of bits and pieces that, together with the Linux kernel, (and thousands of other bits and pieces from myriad developers) go to make up the GNU/Linux operating system.

The FSF can change the licence for those bits and pieces to GPLv3, an updated licence which it plans to release in March. It has been threatening to include conditions in GPLv3 which will make it impossible for Novell to use software released under this licence (GPLv3) if it wants to continue with its Microsoft deal.

The GPLv3 was already in preparation long before there was any inkling about the Novell-Microsoft deal so any conspiracy theories about it can be thrown out of the window right here.



 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
iTWire user statistics Visitors last 30 days
Suscribers
904,266
13,751
#1 independent technology news advertise here
  •   *  
  • Search
  • AdvSeach
  • Login
  • Events
  • FreeStuff
Subscribe to our free e-newsletter
- Advertisement -

Open Sauce - A GNU perspective Subscribe to the RSS
Open Sauce focuses on the wonderful, wacky world of free and open source software where people write great applications and actually allow others to use them without payment.