Cornered! is a blog devoted, most of the time anyway, to telecommunications: local and global issues, technology, people and trends from the perspective of someone who's been reporting, analysing and commenting on the industry since the dark ages (BC - before competition). Sometimes serious, sometimes flippant, sometimes frivolous. Controversial, analytical, informative, amusing, but never boring; a vehicle for examinations of important issues and observations on my encounters and experiences in an industry where polarised views and hyperbole are the norm.
Follow the Australian Telecommunications scene NEWSLETTER- FREE TRIAL Blog
Technology news and Jobs 
Cornered! The wisdom of Phil Burgess, brought to you by the WSJ
Cornered! The wisdom of Phil Burgess, brought to you by the WSJ | The wisdom of Phil Burgess, brought to you by the WSJ |
|
| by Stuart Corner | |
| Thursday, 05 November 2009 | |
  
Featured Whitepaper
5 Best Practices for Smartphone Support
The headline: "Australia's Broadband Blunder; Government tries to seize the Internet's backbone," sets the tone of a piece in which Jenkins tells us, without any reservation or qualification whatsoever that: "The government wants to spend $39 billion to deliver 100 megabits to every household in the next decade, without the slightest idea how it might be done commercially or whether customers, who already can get 21 megabits through wireless in most of the country, would be willing to support NBN's huge costs." (Excuse me while I fall about laughing) Then he tells us that the 'sin' of Sol Trujillo was "to carry out the mission given to him...make Telstra a "private sector, fast-moving company." According to Jenkins "He did so. Head count was slashed (so was the share price but let's not talk about that, shall we). Aging and neglected infrastructure was upgraded. Three different wireless platforms were junked and replaced with the fastest, most-advanced 3G network in the world." Well I count those three wireless platforms as CDMA, 2G GSM and 3G at 2100MHz. Last I heard two of them were still with us. Similarly his accounts of Telstra's battles with the ACCC over access prices leave no room for nuances. It's simply " [Telstra] took regulators to court over mandates requiring it to lease its network to competitors at knockdown rates." Worse than this, he goes on to paint Australia not as a robust democracy with a strong political opposition and with numerous diverse and vocal interests across the spectrum but almost as an oligarchy. "Australia lacks America's bottomless think-tank and K Street resources for publicising policy differences. Its parliamentary government puts all the policy levers, including a ready resort to secrecy, in the ruling party's hands. Australia is a small nation, with a small elite that tends to place limits on burn-the-bridges debate." Maybe Burgess is getting Australia mixed up with Singapore. That's the even smaller nation whose cardinal sin, in Burgess' eyes seems to have been that its majority government-owned telco owns Optus. Oh yes, and that it "executes people". Jenkins tells his readers: "Mr. Burgess no longer lives in Australia and no longer works for Telstra and he certainly doesn't have the appreciation of most of the Australian media (at least Jenkins got that bit right!) - but, by keeping up the fight, he just might be helping Australians avoid a terrible mistake." Well, Jenkins is entitled to his opinions, and so is Burgess, but Jenkins is not entitled to present Burgess's opinions as fact. If Jenkins wants to take a position on the NBN, Trujillo's achievements or anything else to do with Australian telecommunications he needs to do a bit more research before telling his readers that "The NBN is a tremendously awful idea."
This article first appeared in ExchangeDaily, iTWire's daily newsletter for telecommunications professionals. Register here for your free trial.
 |
Tags
| < Next story in category | Previous story in the category > |
|---|
