Cornered!
Cornered! is a blog devoted, most of the time anyway, to telecommunications: local and global issues, technology, people and trends from the perspective of someone who's been reporting, analysing and commenting on the industry since the dark ages (BC - before competition). Sometimes serious, sometimes flippant, sometimes frivolous. Controversial, analytical, informative, amusing, but never boring; a vehicle for examinations of important issues and observations on my encounters and experiences in an industry where polarised views and hyperbole are the norm.
Follow the Australian Telecommunications scene NEWSLETTER- FREE TRIAL

Blog

Technology news and Jobs arrow Cornered! arrow Optus court victory strengthens case for Telstra separation
Optus court victory strengthens case for Telstra separation E-mail
by Stuart Corner   
Sunday, 03 May 2009
Asked by senator Kate Lundy in a Senate Estimates hearing last year: "In the ACCC's view is the current operational separation regime that applies to Telstra an effective mechanism for promoting equivalency between Telstra and its competitors?" Samuel replied: "The short answer is probably no."

He said the ACCC "continue[s] to receive complaints of conduct that suggest that the objective of equivalence, which was the objective of the regime, is not being achieved. According to Samuel, "There have been some instances of conduct since the regime's inception which, while it is not clear they breach the operational separation plan, do not promote the objective of equivalence which was the fundamental objective of the plan in the first place. In relation to the other objective of transparency, there is some additional reporting that the regime provides. However, this has been of limited benefit and is at a highly aggregated level."

He described the regime as "fundamentally unduly complex," saying that "a lot of discretion is left to Telstra. There are limited self-regulatory mechanisms and unduly convoluted processes to implement any corrective action if a problem is identified."

At around the same time, writing in The Telecommunications Journal of Australia, Tony Warren, Telstra's executive director of public affairs, claimed that "There are now firm, enforceable and audited rules and processes in place to ensure the confidentiality of wholesale customer data, the separation of wholesale and retail business units," and asked: "Why do you need structural separation when operational separation already provides volumes of information and transparency around pricing and equivalence of service? There is no systemic discrimination between wholesale and retail that would necessitate structural separation."

In the light of this judgement - and remember it revealed that this was not ad hoc activity by relatively low level executives but a systematic campaign carried out with full knowledge of top level executives and the board -it will be extremely difficult for Telstra to convince the government that anything short of full structural separation will prevent a repeat occurrence, or make it any easier for such to be proven.
This article first appeared in ExchangeDaily, iTWire's daily newsletter for telecommunications professionals. Register here for your free trial.
Register for ExchangeDaily


Powered By Joomla Tags

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to post your comment!



 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
iTWire user statistics Visitors last 30 days
694,279
Subscribers 15,210
#1 independent technology news advertise here
  •   *  
  • Search
  • AdvSeach
  • Login
  • Events
  • FreeStuff

- Advertisement -

Featured Whitepapers

Cornered! - Telecoms blog
Cornered! is a blog on all things tele-communication from the perspective of one who has observed, analysed commented and reported on the industry since the dark ages (BC - before competition).
Follow iTWire on Twitter

About iTWire

iTWire is all about technology news, information, jobs and community for the IT and telecommunications industry professional. Subscribe to our free ICT daily newsletter