Technology news and Jobs arrow VIRTUALISATION arrow Coalition clueless on broadband
Coalition clueless on broadband E-mail
by Stuart Corner   
Wednesday, 05 November 2008
Shadow communications minister, Nick Minchin, has been damning in his criticism of the Rudd Government's broadband policy, but has failed to offer any alternative.

In his first major speech since taking the shadow portfolio from Bruce Billson in September, Minchin told Terrapinn's Broadband Conference in Sydney today that: "In our view [the ALP policy] has been very deeply flawed from the very beginning, It is our view that Labor based its broadband policy on a glib pre-election policy rather than on any realistic or robust public policy approach and now with just three weeks to go the closing date for RFPs, the government is monumentally exposed as this thing starts to unravel."

He continued in similar vein: "In the run up to the election the government's approach was just vague and simplistic. It ignored reality and they gave very little detail...As someone who has been involved in policy development for 30 years I know when something is based on focus groups."

I agree entirely, and have said as much, and more, in these columns on several occasions.

Minchin then went on to make it very clear that the Liberal Party had no stomach for structural separation. Noting that "The government is refusing to say one way or the other what is its position on separation," he said: "My view is that it is far too late in the evolution of telecommunications in Australia to still be discussing the break up of Telstra...I do not believe it is at all realistic to threaten a force break up of the company and I do not believe any Government would attempt it."

Most likely, but let us not forget that structural separation of new infrastructure is not the same as "breaking up Telstra" - a confusion that Telstra has worked very hard to foster. And let us not forget that the time to break up Telstra would have been before the Coalition Government sold it to private investors - a process which Minchin presided over the final stages of as finance minister.

That aside, I would have hoped that Minchin could have had something constructive to say as to how a future Coalition Government would extract Australia from this broadband mess.

After all, it is not at all unrealistic to suggest that it may well be called upon to do so. As Minchin took great delight in reminding the audience, on Labor's pre-election promise the first services of its brave new broadband world should have been coming on line in less than eight weeks. With the government now a year old, there is every possibility that this mess could become an issue for the next election.
CONTINUED



 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
iTWire user statistics Visitors last 30 days
694,279
Subscribers 15,210
#1 independent technology news advertise here
  •   *  
  • Search
  • AdvSeach
  • Login
  • Events
  • FreeStuff

- Advertisement -

Featured Whitepapers

Follow iTWire on Twitter

About iTWire

iTWire is all about technology news, information, jobs and community for the IT and telecommunications industry professional. Subscribe to our free ICT daily newsletter