Technology news and Jobs arrow VIRTUALISATION arrow Is Psystar guilty of sophistry?
Is Psystar guilty of sophistry? E-mail
by Stephen Withers   
Tuesday, 02 September 2008
So Psystar has denied Apple's allegations of copyright and other infringements associated with the sale of its Open Computer. Psystar's Open Computer is assembled from generic parts, and offered for sale with Mac OS X preinstalled as one of the operating system options. Is Psystar putting up fallacious arguments in its defence and counterattack or are its arguments justified?

Psystar made waves in the desktop space when it launched the OpenMac - hurriedly renamed Open Computer - in April.

Apple launched legal proceedings against the company in July, alleging (among other things) trademark and trade dress infringement, and inducement to infringe copyright.

Psystar's response to many of Apple's assertions was to say, in effect, "we know nothing about that, so we deny that it is true." That, to me, smacks of wilful ignorance. It may work between lawyers and judges, but if I were serving on a jury, I'd find it very hard to take seriously anyone that floated such a line.

Here's a good example: on one hand, "PSYSTAR admits that BusinessWeek Magazine has identified the PLAINTIFF as the 'World's Most Innovative Company.'" yet on the other, "PSYSTAR is without information or knowledge as to Consumer Reports' ranking of technical support for or by the PLAINTIFF and on that basis denies the allegation."

My reaction to such an assertion would be "go and find out, and only then are you entitled to assert whether the claim is true or not."

Please read on for a somewhat controversial parallel.



 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
iTWire user statistics Visitors last 30 days
694,279
Subscribers 15,210
#1 independent technology news advertise here
  •   *  
  • Search
  • AdvSeach
  • Login
  • Events
  • FreeStuff

- Advertisement -

Featured Whitepapers

Follow iTWire on Twitter

About iTWire

iTWire is all about technology news, information, jobs and community for the IT and telecommunications industry professional. Subscribe to our free ICT daily newsletter