Cornered!
Cornered! is a blog devoted, most of the time anyway, to telecommunications: local and global issues, technology, people and trends from the perspective of someone who's been reporting, analysing and commenting on the industry since the dark ages (BC - before competition). Sometimes serious, sometimes flippant, sometimes frivolous. Controversial, analytical, informative, amusing, but never boring; a vehicle for examinations of important issues and observations on my encounters and experiences in an industry where polarised views and hyperbole are the norm.
Follow the Australian Telecommunications scene NEWSLETTER- FREE TRIAL

Blog

Technology news and Jobs arrow Cornered! arrow Telstra shoots messenger: accuses economists of producing 'bogus report'
Telstra shoots messenger: accuses economists of producing 'bogus report' E-mail
by Stuart Corner   
Friday, 06 June 2008
Of course, she did not quote the following sentence which read: "However, obtaining precision is not the main objective of this analysis. The main point is to show that it is likely that a significant margin exists between Telstra's required return from the FTTN network and the return that an alternative supplier would require for the same asset, and this margin will translate into hardship for the economy and the community."

Over two decades or reporting on  telecommunications I have seen more reports produced by economic consultancies crunching numbers in support of one or other side of a telecoms argument than I've had hot dinners. It is well beyond by competence to determine the merits of their arguments, but I have come to the conclusion that it is possible to arrive at whatever conclusion you want by choosing the right model and making the right assumptions.

A decade ago both Telstra and the Government used the same consultancy, The LEK Partnership, to arrive at totally different estimates for the cost of meeting the universal service obligation ($250m v $800m)!

The CIE bills itself "a highly respected private economic consultancy providing advice and analysis to Australian and foreign governments, international organisations, and the private sector." It has been in business for 20 years and claims to have "built a reputation for analysing difficult and complex economic issues, and producing well researched, comprehensive and credible economic assessments.

Clearly it has a reputation to protect and for Telstra to dismiss its latest body of word as "a bogus report with no basis is fact and a dishonest distortion" is a slander on the organisation and those who work for it. It is shooting the messenger rather than the message. It's up to Telstra to keep the economists employed and commission its own report to counter its competitor's arguments I'm sure that won't be too difficult.

Powered By Joomla Tags

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to post your comment!



 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
iTWire user statistics Visitors last 30 days
694,279
Subscribers 15,210
#1 independent technology news advertise here
  •   *  
  • Search
  • AdvSeach
  • Login
  • Events
  • FreeStuff

- Advertisement -

Featured Whitepapers

Cornered! - Telecoms blog
Cornered! is a blog on all things tele-communication from the perspective of one who has observed, analysed commented and reported on the industry since the dark ages (BC - before competition).
Follow iTWire on Twitter

About iTWire

iTWire is all about technology news, information, jobs and community for the IT and telecommunications industry professional. Subscribe to our free ICT daily newsletter