The Linux distillery
Bringing the world of Linux to you, David cuts through the tech and shows you how it works and how to use it, in terms that apply to any distro. RSS
IT NEWS           RSS Mastering The Complex Sale
Technology news and Jobs arrow The Linux distillery arrow Microsoft arguments against Linux are bollocks
Microsoft arguments against Linux are bollocks PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 54
PoorBest 
by David M Williams   
Monday, 28 April 2008
Microsoft PR threw down the gauntlet; “see how Windows Server 2008 stacks up versus Linux,” they say. There’s a “Get the Facts” URL being promoted with claims of direct comparisons between the two operating systems. Anyone reading the headlines alone could be fooled into thinking there’s substance to be found.

The URL is www.Microsoft.com/getthefacts which in turn redirects to the Windows Server 2008 subsite. I went into detail on one case study found on this site last week which promised the exciting tale where a major Australian entertainment company – Video Ezy – pitched Windows vs Linux head to head and Windows came out trumps.

However, reading the case study revealed no such comparison took place. The organisation were interested in evaluating the open source route but – and the case study is explicit, this is not just fanciful imagination on my part – one of the team members steered the company away because they spoke of bad experiences with Linux in a previous job.

Mind you, the bad experience was dubious; in essence a Windows shop acquired a smaller company which ran Linux. By rolling out their existing standard operating platform they cut costs. Really, the operating system used was irrelevant; it’s a no brainer that you will gain efficiency and reduce costs by having a standard platform over all your sites.

In the end, to my mind, the solution implemented did not meet the high goals the company had in mind. Disappointingly, it’s most likely budget constraints were the cause – and if an open source solution had been chosen there could have been more bang for buck.

It was a very weak case study. Perhaps it had merits if it were touted as “Microsoft designs solution for Video Ezy” but it was not; it was pitched as a direct battle between the two operating systems, with Microsoft winning. This just was not the case.

Now, don’t get me wrong here; I critiqued the Microsoft case study but that should in no way be taken as a criticism of the company itself – I’m certainly a Video Ezy customer – and definitely not of any individual involved. My point was that it was an abysmal example of a case study pushed by Microsoft showing that it outshines Linux.

You don’t have to look hard on the Microsoft site to see more nonsensical headlines. Listed on the front page of that site right now is this headline:

Why are customers choosing Windows Server 2008 over Linux
HiChina Web Solutions
Using Windows Server 2008, we will be able to increase overall reliability by 20 percent. With that capability, we can host more customer Web sites than we could previously.”

Can this be taken on face value? What do you think? Please read on.

CONTINUED








 
< Next story in category   Previous story in the category >
Subscribe to iTWire's Free daily e-newsletter Delivered daily - FREE
Subscribe to our Technology newsletter, get the latest and stay ahead ...example
* First name:
* Last name:
* Your email address:
* Country:
* Enter the security code shown:

* mandatory
Google
 
You don't need to login to post a comment





Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Subscribe to our free daily newsletter.
9th Annual Business Intelligence
May 8 (8:00 am) - July 16 (11:59 pm), 2008
The drastic change of vendor landscape in 2007, which resulted by the big-time acquisition of the...

Applications open for postgraduate studies in Technical Communication at Swinburne University
May 13 (8:00 am) - September 09 (11:59 pm), 2008
Swinburne University runs two courses offering university-level qualifications to technical commu...

ISTQB Software Testing Certification Training
May 19 (9:00 am) - May 21 (11:59 pm), 2008
HEDLOC ISTQB Foundation Certification Course (3 Days, Sydney) The ISTQB Foundation Certificate i...

ISTQB Foundation Certification Public Training, Sydney, 19th May 2008
May 19 (9:00 am) - May 21 (11:59 pm), 2008
The ISTQB Foundation Certificate is an internationally recognised professional qualification in s...

ISEB/ISTQB Foundation Certificate in Software Testing - Melbourne
May 19 (9:00 am) - May 21 (11:59 pm), 2008
Disqover - Improving Software Quality offers software and systems testers the opportunity to beco...

CeBIT
May 20 (8:00 am) - May 22 (11:59 pm), 2008
CeBIT Australia is Australasia's leading Information & Communications Technology (ICT) event for ...

Free Webinar:Open Source Data Migration with Talend Open Studio
May 20, 2008 (9:00 am - 10:00 am)
This one-hour Webinar will present: - The specific constraints of data migration, including: hi...

Open Source webinar, what a Department of Homeland Security Scan Reveals about Open Source
May 21, 2008 (10:00 am - 11:59 pm)
A SD Times Webinar Wednesday, May 21, 2008, 1:00p.m. EDT / 10:00 a.m. PDT Launched as a joi...

Open Source Webinar
May 21, 2008 (10:00 am - 11:59 pm)
Open Source Uncovered, what a Department of Homeland Security Scan Reveals about Open Source A S...

HP Quality Center Dashboard Public Training, Perth 22nd May 2008
May 22, 2008 (9:00 am - 11:59 pm)
This hands-on instructor-led course covers the features of the Quality Center 9.2 Dashboard. This...
New event listings
SolidWorks Innovation Day (Brisbane and Perth)
October 15, 2008 (All Day)
Hosted by Intercad, SolidWorks’ Innovation Days will give designers, engineers and manufacturers ...

LIXI Industry Forum 2008
September 10, 2008 (All Day)
Wednesday, 10 September 2008 The Westin Sydney The second annual major industry event for the...

Last Day to apply for Mid Year study at Swinburne University
August 1, 2008 (All Day)
Applications close for Swinburne University’s online postgraduate Technical Communication courses.

Energy Logic Symposium- Melbourne
July 8, 2008 (All Day)
Emerson Network Power, Dell, IBM and Cisco show you how to slash data centre energy use without c...

Energy Logic Symposium - Sydney
July 3, 2008 (All Day)
Emerson Network Power, Dell, IBM and Cisco show you how to slash data centre energy use without c...

Energy Logic Symposium
July 1, 2008 (All Day)
Emerson Network Power, Dell, IBM and Cisco show you how to slash data centre energy use without c...

View Full Calendar
Add New Event
Contact , Register , Advertise with iTWire , Links , About iTWire , Feedback , Post your jobs , Events , iTWire site map , Start Blogging , MyBlogLog page
Industry Releases , Submit your release now